15
« on: June 13, 2016, 09:01:50 PM »
In another RaceNY thread, I complained about a race car driver that intentionally brought out a yellow flag. I thought he should have been immediately disqualified. A supporter (or maybe the driver himself) attempted to rationalize his actions. I responded that racing isn’t always fair and the issue quickly died. Since then, I’ve given this situation some more thought. The result is the following:
WHAT IF TAKING A TEST WAS LIKE RACING
Image you’re taking a written test. It doesn’t really matter what kind of test: high school, college, SAT, or even an employment exam. What does matter is that you’re sitting in a room with a bunch of other people taking the same test and you have a fixed amount of time to complete the test. The objective, obviously, is to do better than everyone else in the room.
Let’s say, while taking the test, that your No. 2 pencil breaks for some reason. Maybe there’s a flaw in how the pencil was manufactured. Maybe you pressed (down) too hard causing the lead to break. No matter. There are a couple of solutions – bring out a new No. 2 pencil or sharpen the broken one. In both cases, you resolve the issue and resume taking the test.
If taking a test were like racing, breaking a pencil (for whatever reason) would require you to replace the pencil, turn in your answer sheet, receive a new one, and restart the test from the beginning. How fair is that?
Let’s say that the person (we’ll say gentleman) in the back row is having a difficult time with the test. He finds the questions perplexing but does his best hoping that his score will be good enough. He continues to struggle and eventually just gives up. He spins around in his chair, jumps up, and heads to the exit. You continue on hoping to achieve a top score.
If taking a test were like racing, you would almost certainly be penalized for the back row gent’s lack of test taking ability. If you were doing very well on the test, you might even have to restart the test from the beginning under certain circumstances – most certainly if (eye) contact was made. How fair is that?
Finally, while taking a test, the guy sitting next to you glances at you answer sheet and copies your answer. The proctor immediately notices the incident and tells your neighbor to turn in his exam sheet and exit the room for improper actions. Although your progress was momentarily interrupted, you resume answering the test questions.
If taking a test were like racing, you might be penalized by having to restart the test from the beginning. Not that you did anything wrong but you were involved in the incident! The guy did copy your answer. How fair is that?
Have I made my point? How well you do on a test is entirely up to you. It has nothing to do with the others in the room. Racing, on the other hand, is very different. How well you do is very often dependent on factors beyond your control such as debris that causes your tire to go flat, the lapped car that spins in front of you, or the guy running next to you that gets loose and runs into you.
Racing isn’t fair. Never has been and never will be. Maybe that’s why I like it so much. Nonetheless, if you intentionally bring out the caution, you should be immediately disqualified or, at a minimum, scored a lap down.