We did the same! 1968...saw Bonnie and Clyde at the Paramount Theater on Mortimer Street (the RKO around the corner was boarded up by that time). Spent all our money at the Cigar Box novelty store too (Jay's was upstairs I think)...
Yeah, I remember the RKO, on Clinton Avenue. I think the first "date" I took to the movies, we went to see 'The Graduate', and it was showing there. Went on a Sunday afternoon, because I didn't have a "night drivers license". To the best of my recollection, Jay's was two storefronts north of the Main and Clinton corner, where the Fanny Farmer candy store was right at the corner....under the HUGE Genesee Beer billboard, with the big image of "Genny the Beer Girl"....
Something I don't under stand...the website censor. In my previous post, I used the word for dumb, that begins with the letter "s", and the site replaced it with asterisks. Why?